There seems to be a discrepancy over who won the battle between ACP and UMA. The picture in question is the one below that Batista took. The question is who had the lead at this point. UMA argues that they had more soldiers. Jedi’s argument is that some of these soldiers are not UMA soldiers but are other penguins wearing red who were present prior to the battle.
Apologies for the poor quality, it was not my picture.
Here are my arguments:
- This picture was taken prior to the battle. Though it was only one minute before, many of the random penguins that had turned red while UMA was waiting for the beginning of the battle left after we charged and joke bombed UMA for the first 2-3 minutes.
- The rules state that you gain a point for having more soldiers than the opponent for 5 minutes straight. Just because UMA had more soldiers at this one single moment should not affect the scoring at all. Even if they did hold the majority at this point, which I do not believe is true, they should not be awarded points for this single instance.
- Some of the soldiers marked by Batista were not UMA soldiers. The ones circled in blue were penguins that I could read the names of clearly enough to check the UMA ranks and say that they were in fact, not ranked members of UMA. The other blue ones were clearly not in UMA uniform (one at the top was even the color green), wearing items such as a crown and pink sweatshirt/scarf. The ones circled in green were not necessarily UMA soldiers, but I could not tell whether they were or not, so I have including since I cannot be sure.
My final count is that there are at most, 21 UMA (with 4 in question), whereas there are at most 26 ACP soldiers (maybe as few as 23). Regardless of the total number of ACP soldiers, there are not enough actual UMA soldiers for there to be a majority, and even if UMA and ACP were even, no points should be awarded because neither held the significant majority. It is my belief that after this point, UMA lost soldiers throughout the battle while ACP gained soldiers, resulting in the recorded majority that ACP had at the conclusion of the battle. I hope that this sheds some light on the subject so that we can make a proper decision.
Boomer
P.S.~If any of the judges would like to talk with me about this, I am open to any arguments you may have.
Filed under: ACP |
That’s a very convincing arguement to UMA’s claim.
Boomer: Wow, Person agrees? 😯
It’s odd. I mean, it’s not like it’s against the rules to be popular. From the looks of that picture, the UMA had far more people than the ACP. I don’t see anyone just “wearing red” and even if they were, there would be too many of them to consider it “casual’ red-wearing
Boomer: I disagree, but even so, but they did not hold the majority for long enough to receive points. Their is no proof at this time to prove that they still had more soldiers after the five minutes were up.
Yes it is.
Guys, there’s a hacker on the loose and he is threatening to hack me, Nate and Sheila!
cool beans
Boomer: lol
Oh well. Dont worry about it. Like I said in the Army News/RPF Big News Post, UMA is going to move on anyway. Because Bobcat is going to find a phantom rule or something and we r going to lose. End of story, “Congrats UMA on beating ACP by a rule that doesnt exist”. There is always next year.
Boomer: I wouldn’t be so sure. They just need clarification.
lets just face it,both UMA and ACP have n00bs join but they should count and i dont think that 1 minute will change the number of soldiers.
Boomer: I agree, I do not think points should be awarded for either side based on this picture.
Miroos, are you talking about me? You’re scared aren’t you? Here’s an update on my hacking: about an hour ago I successfully got in to Nate’s account. Because you’ve commented on his site, I can access the dashboard to see your IP address. With access to that I can track your IP and watch your every move. While I was at it I added myself to the USCP site. I’m also working on a hack that will completely change Club Penguin.
-HN
ACP CAN FAF AND ACP MAKE A TREATY? WE NEED AN ALLY AND IF YOU AGREE WILL YOU AVERIZE? PLEASE ACCEPT IF YOU DO GET ON CP TOMORROW AT 6:30 P.M CENTRAL TIME. THIS IS FAF LEADER FRESCA39 AND PLEASE ACCEPT!
Another update: I made quick work of hacking Miroos and Sheila’s accounts.
-HN
BOOMER DO YOU ACCEPT?!?!??!?!?!?!?!?!?!
imposters 🙄
Boomer no offence to u or ACP, but you cant just change UMA troops, and when you said we “lost” troops its when we did our first and succesful attack of the frenzy. We used the frenzy and numerous UMA troops spammed CP so therw ould be so many bubbles u couldnt see the penguins( not all the way of crouse) and travel to an are to get acp in the middle and sorround witch is wat we did, we didnt lose troops we just split up. The frenzy ALSO gave us a huge advantage but nobody counted it as a point, thats not really fair. In the end of the battle we formed a line over the plaza path called the plaza protection against ACP witch gave us EVEN MORE soldiers and nobody stiill counted it as a point, If somebody does count those points and should count them, UMA won.
Boomer: You need to hold the significant majority for 5 minutes which neither army really did. It was too close to call most of the time, so I’m guessing that it came down to charges.
comment 1 of 2
Ok I finnaly get to comment on something I had ALOT to do these past weeks between band and SEMESTER EXAMS, and homework and a detention, and work ( all these due with middle school).
Ok ( this may sound just rude and like i don’t have time for commenting ) good job acp!!!